Most ASWB students spend 80% of their time reading and 20% practicing. The highest scorers do the exact opposite.
As you've prepared for the ASWB exam, you've probably wondered: Should I focus on reading study guides or taking practice tests? The short answer: Overall, practice tests are significantly more effective for exam success.
Both methods have their place, but understanding when and how to use each one strategically can make the difference between passing and not. Let's explore why practice testing is so powerful and how to combine both approaches for maximum results.
Educational psychology research consistently demonstrates that retrieval practice—actively recalling information from memory—is far more effective than passive review for long-term retention and performance.
A landmark study published in Science found that students who took practice tests retained 50% more information after one week compared to those who repeatedly studied the same material. Even more striking: the practice test group maintained their advantage even after longer intervals.
For professional licensing exams like the ASWB, this difference becomes even more pronounced because you're not just memorizing facts—you're learning to apply knowledge under pressure.
While study guides build foundational knowledge, practice tests develop the specific skills you need to succeed on exam day. Here's what makes them so much more effective for test preparation:
When you read that "empathy involves understanding and sharing another person's emotional experience," it feels familiar. Your brain says, "Yes, I know this." But consider this scenario:
A teenage client tells you, "My parents are getting divorced and it's all my fault. I should have been a better kid." Which response best demonstrates empathy?
A. "Divorce is never a child's fault. Your parents made this decision for adult reasons."
B. "It sounds like you're carrying a heavy burden of guilt about your parents' situation."
C. "Many teenagers feel this way during divorce. These feelings are normal."
D. "What makes you think you could have prevented their divorce?"
Why the wrong answers miss the mark:
Option B is correct because it directly reflects and validates what the client is experiencing without trying to fix, normalize, or question it—the essence of empathy.
This analysis reveals something crucial: you can't learn to distinguish between "helpful" and "empathetic" responses just by reading definitions. You need repeated exposure to scenarios where these distinctions matter.
The ASWB exam demands 4 hours of sustained focus while recognizing question patterns that you can only learn through exposure. Study guides let you read at your own pace with unlimited breaks. Practice tests simulate the real cognitive demands: time pressure, mental fatigue around question 120, and the pattern recognition that comes from seeing "what to do first" scenarios dozens of times.
You won't internalize that assessment usually comes before intervention by reading about it—you need to experience it across multiple contexts until it becomes instinctive.
Students who rely primarily on study guides often report feeling blindsided by the exam format, even though they "knew the material." Those who practice extensively report feeling calm and prepared because the actual exam feels familiar, not foreign. When you've been there before (even in simulation), anxiety drops and performance rises.
Here's how to integrate both methods into your 90-day preparation plan:
Study guides aren't obsolete—they're foundational tools that work best when paired strategically with practice testing:
For Building Initial Understanding: When you're encountering new concepts like systems theory or crisis intervention models, study guides provide the structured learning foundation you need.
For Targeted Knowledge Gaps: After practice tests reveal specific weaknesses (like scoring below 60% on ethics questions), study guides offer focused explanations to fill those precise holes.
For Quick Reference and Review: During your final preparation weeks, study guides are invaluable for rapid review of key concepts and last-minute clarification.
For Understanding the "Why": When you get practice questions wrong, study guides help you grasp the underlying principles and reasoning, not just the correct answer.
Many students gravitate toward study guides because they feel productive and comfortable. Reading feels like learning. But comfort is often the enemy of growth.
If your study method feels easy, it's probably not preparing you adequately for the challenge ahead.
Some students try to master every topic in their study guides before attempting practice questions. This is backwards. You don't need perfect knowledge to benefit from practice tests—in fact, struggling with questions you're not ready for is part of what makes practice so effective.
Not all practice questions are created equal. Some study guides include questions that are too easy, poorly worded, or don't match the actual exam style. This gives you false confidence.
Invest in practice tests that accurately mirror the ASWB format and difficulty level, like those from Social Work Test Prep, which are specifically designed to match real exam conditions.
To maximize the benefit of practice testing:
Simulate Real Conditions: No phone, no breaks, time limits enforced.
Review Thoroughly: Don't just check your score. Analyze why you got questions wrong and, equally important, why you got questions right.
Track Your Patterns: Keep notes on recurring mistakes. If you consistently miss ethics questions, that's actionable data.
Vary Your Timing: Take some tests in the morning, some in the afternoon. Find out when your brain performs best.
Embrace Difficulty: If you're weak in group work, take more group work questions, not fewer.
Study guides help you learn content. Practice tests help you pass exams.
If you only have time for one approach, choose practice tests every time. The students who score highest aren't necessarily those who know the most facts—they're the ones who can consistently apply their knowledge under exam conditions.
Your social work career depends on passing this exam, not on perfect theoretical knowledge. Practice tests prepare you for the reality of test day: time pressure, complex scenarios, and the need to choose the best answer from several good options.
Ready to put practice testing to work? Social Work Test Prep offers some of the most realistic (and reasonably priced!) ASWB practice exams available, with detailed explanations for every question and performance tracking to guide your study.
Don't just study harder—study smarter with the method that works best.
Right now, get SWTP's online practice exams at a reduced price. Just $39. Get additional savings when buying more than one exam at a time-- less than $30 per exam!
Keep going till you pass. Extensions are free.
To receive our free study guide and get started!